top of page

Outsourcing Brand Design in the Public Sector: 4 Key Questions for Evaluating Design Firms

6 hours ago
5 min read

Under Taiwan's Government Procurement Act, procurement of services (including design services) exceeding NT$100,000 must follow the procedures set out in the Act. According to the Public Construction Commission of the Executive Yuan's statistics over the years, roughly 15% to 20% of design procurement cases end up being re-tendered. In most cases the reason isn't an insufficient budget; it's that the selection committee and case officers can't clearly judge “which design firm is truly capable of doing this project well.” The biggest challenge in outsourcing public-sector design is the lack of evaluation capability, not the size of the budget.


A framework for evaluating outsourced public-sector brand design, Good&Also

Can They Clearly Explain “Why It Was Designed This Way” in Their Work?


The quality of a portfolio isn't just about how it looks; it's about whether the design decisions are clearly explained. Across its experience serving more than 30 brands, Good&Also has observed that the design firms that can clearly explain “why this color, why this typeface, why this layout best suits this organization” are the teams with genuine brand strategy capability, rather than ones that pitch on aesthetic instinct.



Before Producing Any Designs, Did They First Ask You “Who Is This Brand Talking To”?


For a design firm with brand strategy capability, the first step after a project kicks off isn't opening the design software; it's confirming the target audience. If a firm presents a first round of designs without having done any audience research, that is a clear warning sign. The starting point of brand design is always “who this brand is talking to, and whose problem it solves.”

A good design firm will hold a brand strategy workshop after taking on the project, so the client organization's key stakeholders can align on the core direction together: who the brand serves, how it differs from similar organizations, and what impression the target audience should form of the organization. This workshop isn't an optional add-on; it's an indispensable preliminary step in brand design. Without it, the visual design that follows can easily become a cosmetic exercise with no sense of direction.


Does the Design Process Include Co-Creation and Stage-by-Stage Sign-Offs?


The most common failure pattern in outsourced public-sector design projects goes like this: the firm submits a design, the client organization says it isn't right, it goes back and forth several times, and under deadline pressure the work is reluctantly accepted, leaving both sides dissatisfied. The root of the problem is the lack of a co-creation mechanism along the way: the design firm worked in a one-shot proposal mode instead of co-creating in stages.

A responsible design firm will divide brand design into three clear stages for confirmation:

  • Stage 1: Confirming the strategic direction (target audience, brand positioning, core message)

  • Stage 2: Confirming the visual direction (mood board, first draft of the color system, typeface direction)

  • Stage 3: Confirming the complete identity system (logo, color guidelines, application examples)

Each stage has clear deliverables and a sign-off procedure, ensuring that the final design has already been validated by both sides along the way, rather than handed over in one go with the outcome left to chance. A design firm with stage-by-stage sign-offs usually also has enough project management capability to keep a project moving steadily through the relatively cumbersome administrative procedures of the public sector.


On the Quote, Are “Strategy Research” and “Design Execution” Listed Separately?


Design firms with strategic capability usually list “brand strategy research” and “visual design execution” as two separate items on their quote. If a firm's quote has only one lump sum for “brand design,” it usually means strategy research is missing from the workflow, or has been glossed over and folded into the visual design fee. From a brand consultant's point of view, this is the most direct indicator of whether a design firm is strategy-centered.

According to general market rates in Taiwan's design consulting industry, complete brand strategy research (including competitor analysis, audience research, and a brand strategy workshop) accounts for roughly 20% to 30% of the total project fee. An honest design firm should be able to explain the logic behind that fee breakdown clearly, so you know which stage the money goes to and what it produces, rather than lumping all the fees into a single figure that leaves room for haggling.


Frequently Asked Questions


In Public-Sector Design Procurement, Can the Tender Specifications Require Strategic Capability?

Yes. Under the “bidder qualifications” or “work plan” requirements in the tender specifications, you can add conditions such as “describe your methods and process for brand strategy research” and “attach an explanation of the reasoning behind each major design decision in the proposal.” These conditions effectively screen for design firms with strategic capability, rather than simply comparing whose visual style is more appealing on presentation day.


If a Design Firm Says It Wants to Hold a Workshop First, Which Budget Item Does the Fee Fall Under?

The fee for a brand strategy workshop is usually included in the “strategy research” stage, as part of the project's preliminary work. If a design firm charges separately for the workshop, the quote should clearly specify the workshop's scope (hours, number of participants, documents produced), so you can judge whether the fee is reasonable and list it explicitly as one of the deliverables in the procurement documents.


With a Limited Budget, Is It Still Worth an NPO Hiring a Design Firm with Brand Strategy Capability?

Yes. For an NPO with a limited budget, “getting it right once” is better value than “doing it cheaply and revising over and over.” Many design firms with strategic capability also offer flexible pricing for NPOs, or can help obtain design resources through government grant programs such as those of the Ministry of Culture and the Ministry of Health and Welfare's Social and Family Affairs Administration. The key is to ask clearly about the workflow during evaluation, rather than looking only at the final quoted figure.


Finding the Right Design Partner Matters More Than Finding the Most Stylish Design Firm


The key to success in an outsourced public-sector design project isn't finding “the most stylish design firm,” but finding the design partner “best able to help you think the problem through.” These 4 questions can help you quickly filter out partners with genuine strategic capability during a tender or comparative invitation process, and set clearer expectations during the collaboration, so both sides can move the design work forward on a shared understanding.

If this article has you wondering whether your organization lacks an evaluation framework when outsourcing design, we invite you to book a Brand Checkup. We'll help you map out where things stand from a strategic perspective and find the single most important point of entry. Book a Brand Checkup

 
 
 

Comments


​Let's Build Your Brand Together

​If you have any thoughts on brand strategy, brand naming, brand positioning, or brand design, please get in touch with us

我們會於工作日六個小時內與您聯繫

​

Phone
+886.2.2633.6189

​Subscribe to our latest brand insights

謝謝您的訂閱,請查閱您的信箱確認!

15F., No. 112, Sec. 1, Xinshi 3rd Rd., Tamsui Dist., New Taipei City 251, Taiwan

© 2026 Good&Also All Rights Reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page