top of page

The Hardest Part of a Public Market Makeover: Making Dozens of Stalls Look Like One Family

6 hours ago
6 min read

In a single public market, there may be thirty stalls, and with them thirty signboard typefaces, thirty shades of red, and thirty signs nailed up in thirty different eras. This is what Good&Also saw on its first site survey for the Zhudong Hakka Market brand project. The hardest part of a public market makeover is often not designing a beautiful identity, but making dozens of stall vendors, each running their own show, look visually like one and the same place. According to brand consistency research by the brand management platform Marq, maintaining a consistent brand presentation brings an average revenue increase of 23%. But in a public market where ownership is fragmented and every vendor has their own ideas, consistency is almost the most extravagant thing you can ask for.


Unifying stall visuals in a public market makeover: what the Zhudong Hakka Market shows about implementing identity in public markets, by Good&Also

Why Is It So Hard to Unify the Look of a Public Market?


The fundamental reason a public market's visuals are hard to unify is that it has no single brand owner. Vendors each rent their own stalls and run their own businesses, and the signboards are the result of layer upon layer built up over different eras, by different sign makers, on different budgets.

The public sector manages the physical facilities and the leases; rarely is anyone specifically responsible for what the market as a whole looks like. And what vendors care about most is whether their own stall gets noticed, not the overall feel of the market. Any proposal that calls for uniformity is easily read as erasing their individuality.

Seen from another angle, it becomes clearer: a public market is not one brand, but dozens of small brands sharing one roof. This is also its biggest difference from an ordinary corporate brand. What you are dealing with is not just design, but the will of dozens of people. This is really the same principle we discuss in 4 Steps to Brand Positioning: align first, then design.


On Which Three Levels Should You Work to Unify Stall Visuals?


Unifying a public market's visuals doesn't mean making every stall identical; it means building a shared language on three levels. Being clear about which level should be unified and which should be left open is the key to the whole project's success or failure.

  • The first level is the public level: the market's front door and wayfinding. The main entrance identity, the overall naming, the wayfinding system, and public colors and typefaces all belong here. It is led by the public sector, can improve the overall feel without vendors' sign-off, and is the easiest part to establish first.

  • The second level is the stall framework level, which amounts to giving every stall a shared frame. The signboard size modules, background color bands, stall numbering system, and material specifications are all consistent. The outside of the frame is unified, while what goes inside the frame is allowed its own personality.

  • The third level is the vendor-owned level: each stall's own expression. Vendors' own product names, merchandise displays, and handwritten price boards all sit at this level and should be deliberately preserved, because this is precisely where a traditional market's vitality comes from.

In the Zhudong case, Good&Also focused its effort on the first two levels: first establishing the market's overall identity and wayfinding, then giving each stall a set of modular signboard frames. Color is the key lever here. Multiple color studies, including the frequently cited statistic from Loyola University in the US, indicate that consistent color can raise brand recognition by up to 80%. We discuss the same logic in 4 behind-the-scenes decisions in a brand color system. As for the repeated trade-offs behind the wayfinding system, those are collected in the article 4 Behind-the-Scenes Decisions in Public-Sector Wayfinding Design.

To sum up the principle in one sentence: good public market visuals are unified just enough, so that people recognize at a glance that this is one market, yet can still tell who each stall is.


How Can a Public Market's Visual System Be Implemented on a Limited Budget?


Budgets for public market makeovers are usually tight. For a visual system to really be implemented, three things are key: modularity to keep costs down, choosing durable materials, and working with the public sector's review and maintenance cycles.

  • Modularity lowers the cost per stall. With one replicable signboard frame, the more stalls there are, the lower the design cost amortized across each stall. The number of stalls is the variable that most needs to be worked out clearly with the public sector at the proposal stage.

  • Choose materials that are weather-resistant and easy to maintain. Markets are humid and full of cooking fumes. Choose the wrong material, and within six months it fades and peels, and the whole market is back to square one. Material decisions matter no less than the visuals themselves.

  • Write it as a manual vendors can understand. Visual guidelines can't be a spec sheet only designers can read. They have to become a user manual that vendors will actually flip through and can follow; only then can the unity last.

It is worth noting that the market's spatial atmosphere is itself a marketing tool. As early as 1973, the marketing scholar Philip Kotler proposed the concept of atmospherics, pointing out that the overall sensory environment of a store directly affects how long consumers stay and their willingness to buy. This is also why a public market makeover can't stop at a single key visual wall; identity, wayfinding, and stall signboards have to be designed as one system. We have laid out the complete public-sector process, from bidding and proposal to final acceptance, in 5 Key Visual Decisions in the Public-Sector Identity System Design Process.

The last thing, often overlooked yet the most fatal, is governance afterward. Without a set of maintenance rules and a replacement mechanism, a market that has been unified often grows back into everyone doing their own thing within a year or two. This is also a lesson Good&Also has confirmed again and again on public-sector visual system projects: before you hand the system over, make sure someone can take it on.


Frequently Asked Questions


What if the market's vendors don't want to change their signboards?

Start with the public level and the wayfinding system. This part doesn't require vendors' cooperation and can immediately improve the overall feel of the whole market. Stall signboards can then be replaced gradually on a voluntary basis with subsidies, while preserving space for vendors' own displays to reduce resistance. Unity is a process, not a one-time order.

Will unifying stall visuals make the market lose its human warmth?

No, provided the design unifies only the framework, not the content. Truly good public market visuals let each stall show itself within a shared frame. Human warmth comes from the vendors themselves and their goods, not from signboards that all look different.

How should you estimate the visual budget for a public market makeover?

It usually splits into two parts: the overall identity and wayfinding are a one-time cost, while the stall signboard modules are priced by the number of stalls. The more stalls there are, the more you need modular design to keep the cost per stall down. This is also the part that most needs to be explained clearly to the public sector at the proposal stage.

Why do public-sector market makeover projects put so much emphasis on ongoing maintenance?

Because a public market is alive: vendors change and signboards get damaged. Without a visual user manual that vendors can understand and a set of maintenance rules, a unified market often grows back into its old state of everyone doing their own thing within a year or two, and the up-front investment is effectively wasted.


Conclusion: Unify Just Enough, and the Market Stays Both One Place and Those Dozens of People


The real challenge of a public market makeover has never been design skill; it is governance: how to build a shared language everyone is willing to follow while respecting the individuality of dozens of vendors. From the Zhudong Hakka Market to public markets elsewhere, Good&Also's experience is this: first establish the public level and wayfinding that the public sector can lead, then use modular stall frames to give the market a consistent skeleton, and finally leave each stall's expression to the vendors themselves. Unify just enough, and the market stays both one place and those dozens of people.


Further Reading



If this article has you wondering whether your own brand faces a similar problem, book a Brand Checkup. We'll help you map where you stand from a strategic angle and find the single most important point of entry. Book a Brand Checkup

 
 
 

Comments


​Let's Build Your Brand Together

​If you have any thoughts on brand strategy, brand naming, brand positioning, or brand design, please get in touch with us

我們會於工作日六個小時內與您聯繫

​

Phone
+886.2.2633.6189

​Subscribe to our latest brand insights

謝謝您的訂閱,請查閱您的信箱確認!

15F., No. 112, Sec. 1, Xinshi 3rd Rd., Tamsui Dist., New Taipei City 251, Taiwan

© 2026 Good&Also All Rights Reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page