Should a City Hire an Artist or a Brand Design Company? Breaking Down the Identity of Taoyuan's Dalongmen Historic Trails
On the afternoon of November 1, 2026, the Taoyuan City Government launched the Dalongmen Historic Trails brand at Sankeng Nature Ecological Park in Longtan, with Deputy Mayor Su Chun-pin in attendance. According to United Daily News and Storm Media, the city partnered with the Taiwan Thousand Miles Trail Association and the Taiwan Raknus Selu Trail Association to bring together the historic trail resources of the Daxi, Longtan, and Shimen areas, and a Taoyuan City Government news release announced it at the same time. In this Good&Also brand breakdown, we look at how the work on a place brand's identity should be divided.

On the identity side, United Daily News reports that artist Xiao Qing-yang helped design the brand's imagery: a hexagon as the base, with three leaves forming the image of a path. We want to use this case to answer the question public-sector project officers most often get stuck on: should a place brand go to an artist or to a brand design company? Good&Also's answer is that it is not an either-or choice. Before commissioning, break down clearly whether what you are buying is a mark or a system.
What challenge did it face: why does a 65-kilometer network of historic trails need a place brand?
What the Dalongmen Historic Trails need to solve is the problem of three districts sharing one brand. According to the Department of Tourism's explanation, the network is planned around seven community clusters, Kanjin, Sanceng, Baiji, Lingtan, Sanqiashui, Shimen, and Sankeng, linked by a loop of about 65 kilometers, as recorded by both United Daily News and Storm Media.
At the launch, Su Chun-pin said these trails were once the industrial arteries of tea, camphor, and forestry; Taoyuan has taken in a large number of new residents over the past few decades, and the trails are exactly the vehicle that links history and culture with the feelings of everyday life (United Daily News). This means the brand has to win over not only hikers, but also people who live in Taoyuan and have never walked these paths.
The stories along the route are dense, too. The Longtan Shengji Pavilion, a traditional pavilion for burning paper inscribed with written characters, was saved from demolition through the efforts of elder figures such as Chung Chao-cheng and Huang Yung-sung, and a local guiding association still holds a ceremony every year to send off the ashes of the written paper. At Yongfu Temple at the end of Sankeng Old Street, door god paintings created by Chang Chien-kuang 60 years ago were restored this year through the Hundred Temple Doors Project (Storm Media).
From a brand consultant's perspective, this is the most typical challenge for a place brand: too many resources, not too few. Seven community clusters, three districts, two civic associations, plus dozens of story spots. Without a shared umbrella name, travelers will only remember individual sights, not a trail network. Good&Also's judgment is that the name Dalongmen first solves what to call it, and the identity then has to solve how it gets recognized.
What judgment did it make: can one hexagon and three leaves hold up a place brand identity?
Based on the public statements, Good&Also's reading is that this project chose to unify the three districts with a single, simple mark. Xiao Qing-yang explained that the identity is built on a hexagon, with three leaves forming the image of a path that symbolizes the three historic trail areas of Daxi, Longtan, and Shimen, aiming to present the area's natural and historical character through simple visuals (United Daily News). Storm Media put it this way: to give the historic trails both aesthetic appeal and recognizability, the city invited him to help create the brand identity.
Good&Also believes this mark gets one key thing right: it turns administrative boundaries into a natural image. Each of the three leaves represents one district, yet together they form a single shape. The signal it sends is that the three districts belong to the same path, not that three districts are jointly running an event. For a brand that has to integrate resources across districts, this works better than drawing any single landmark, because the moment you draw a Daxi landmark, Longtan and Shimen will ask where they are.
At the same launch, the Taiwan Thousand Miles Trail Association donated a commemorative bench called the Beginning of a Thousand Miles, designed on the structure of the Chinese character for “thousand” and placed at the starting point in Sankeng Nature Ecological Park. It symbolizes this network connecting with northern Taiwan's Tamsui-Kavalan Trails and the Raknus Selu Trail, as reported by both United Daily News and Storm Media.
The bench is a heartfelt gift from the association and a fine image for a starting point. But from a brand system perspective, once a trail network has two or more visual languages, someone has to decide how they coexist: which is primary, which is secondary, and the spacing and proportions when they appear together. Good&Also's reading is that this is exactly where the next stage of work begins once the mark is done.
What did it give up: why doesn't a local tourism brand launch the whole network at once?
From the public information, the Dalongmen Historic Trails gave up at least three things. What follows is Good&Also's reading based on the news coverage and does not represent the city government's internal decision-making process.
Giving up a full-network launch: of the seven community clusters, only the Sankeng route is being rolled out this year, paired with a hand-drawn map, a stamp collection activity, and small group tour itineraries to follow (United Daily News); Storm Media called it a demonstration route. Good&Also believes this is the right order. Use one route to test whether the map, stamp collection, and signage work well, then replicate it across the other six clusters. That is far cheaper than launching seven routes at once and going back to fix them.
Giving up each district's independence in naming: Daxi, Longtan, and Shimen each have their own name recognition, and placing them all under Dalongmen means each district has to give up part of its own name. This is the hardest part of any place brand to negotiate, but without that concession, travelers end up with three unrelated brochures.
Giving up on telling every story through imagery: the mark uses only a hexagon and three leaves. The Shengji Pavilion, the Yongfu Temple door gods, and the industrial history of tea and camphor are not drawn into it. Good&Also sees this as a mature trade-off. The stories are left to the map, interpretive signs, and guided walks, while the mark is only responsible for being remembered.
These three sacrifices buy a starting point that can be used over the long term. The cost is equally clear: all the work left behind falls on the system outside the mark, including how the seven community clusters will extend it, how the two associations' logos will be co-displayed, and whether future small group tour operators can use the mark.
Principles to take away: when commissioning a place brand identity, who should handle the mark, the system, and implementation?
Before commissioning a place brand identity, split the work into three stages, the mark, the system, and implementation, and ask clearly who is responsible for each. The artist provides the mark; a brand design company or consultant builds the system and the implementation guidelines. This is a division of labor, not a rivalry.
The mark: the name and the core image. It suits an artist or designer with a personal style who can tell a story, and the output is a shape that can be remembered.
The system: colors, typefaces, icons, layouts, partner co-branding guidelines, and version control. This stage determines whether multiple community clusters, multiple associations, and future partner businesses can all use the same set of rules, and it is usually the work of a brand design company or consultant.
Implementation: the actual specifications and production oversight for signage, maps, stamp cards, interpretive signs, and event materials. It is the most easily underestimated stage, and the one most likely to start drifting off course by the third year.
In Good&Also's identity project for the Zhudong Hakka Market, we split the system into a public layer, a stall framework layer, and a vendor-owned layer, so that many different users could share one set of rules while each keeping their own expression. The structure of a trail network is very similar: each community cluster is like a stall, and Dalongmen is like the market's main signboard. Good&Also's judgment is that the real difficulty of a place brand is not the mark, but who maintains the guidelines.
When writing tender requirements or a commission brief, you can check yourself with three questions:
Do the deliverables include a brand guidelines manual, or just a logo file?
When partners want to place their own logos alongside the brand, who approves it?
When the second and third routes go live, who is responsible for extending the design?
If you cannot answer these three questions, what you have bought is a mark. A mark matters, but it needs a system to go far. If you want to compare vendors, see the evaluation method in how to choose a brand design company in Taiwan; for the preparation the public sector should do before looking for a brand design company, compare the Dacun Dahao case; and the procurement process for an identity system is laid out in 5 key decisions in public-sector identity system design.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should a local tourism brand identity go to an artist or a brand design company?
It depends on which stage you are missing. If you need a memorable mark with a story behind it, an artist is a great fit; if you need a set of colors, typefaces, signage, and co-branding rules shared by multiple organizations, look for a brand design company or consultant. Many place brands need both, and the key is to write the division of labor clearly into the commission.
Who designed the Dalongmen Historic Trails identity, and what does it mean?
According to United Daily News, artist Xiao Qing-yang helped design the brand imagery: a hexagon as the base, with three leaves forming the image of a path, symbolizing the three historic trail areas of Daxi, Longtan, and Shimen.
Besides a logo, what deliverables should a place brand identity include?
At minimum, it should include color and typeface guidelines, an icon and map vocabulary, templates for signage and interpretive signs, partner co-branding rules, and a version control process. These determine whether the brand still looks the same in its second and third years.
Why is it recommended that a place brand start with one demonstration route?
A single demonstration route lets you test the map, stamp collection, signage, and tour itineraries at the same time, and when problems turn up, you only have to fix one route. According to United Daily News, the Dalongmen Historic Trails are rolling out the Sankeng route first this year, which is exactly this approach.
Conclusion: a good mark needs a system to carry it far
The Dalongmen Historic Trails show a good beginning for a place brand: using one name and one simple mark to bring three districts and seven community clusters onto the same path. What decides how far the brand can go from here is whether anyone is responsible for, and keeps maintaining, the shared rules that sit outside the mark.
If this article has you wondering whether your own brand faces a similar problem, we welcome you to book a Brand Checkup. We will look at where you stand from a strategic perspective and help you find the single most important place to start. Book a Brand Checkup



Comments