top of page

Where Does a Brand Design Fee Go? Breaking Down the Controversy over Hsinchu City's NT$1.2 Million City Identity

2 days ago
7 min read

On June 18, 2026, the Hsinchu City Government unveiled its city brand identity, Carry on!. Six days later, netizens were questioning it as a waste of public money. The city government quickly issued a public explanation: the project's total budget was NT$1.2 million, it was carried out under government procurement procedures, and it covered brand strategy research, logo design, a standard typeface, color guidelines and application design, and an image animation and marketing video production, six items in total.

This is the case for this installment of Good&Also's brand breakdown series. What concerns Good&Also is not whether the logo looks good, but a question every client runs into: where does a brand design fee actually go, and why can the same number be understood as two completely different things by the people paying for it and the people watching from the sidelines?


Concept illustration of a brand design fee broken down into multiple deliverables, Good&Also

Where Exactly Did the NT$1.2 Million Brand Design Fee Go?


The answer is six items, and half of them are not identity design. According to the city government's explanation, the budget covered brand strategy research, logo design, a standard typeface, color guidelines and application design, and an image animation and marketing video production, consistent with the items listed in June 24 reports by Next Apple News and CNEWS.

Sort this list and the core of identity design is really the logo, the logotype, the color guidelines, and the application design; strategy research belongs to upfront investigation; the animation and video are content production, a different profession from identity design with a different cost structure. A single commission bought research, design, and video production at the same time, and was then compressed by the public into one number to be judged.

From a brand consultant's perspective, the real problem in this controversy is not the amount. It is that the procurement list was never translated into language ordinary people could understand. The public used the framework of "NT$1.2 million for one logo" to judge a commission that included video production. The two sides were not talking about the same thing at all, and a gap like that cannot be closed with a clarification statement.

For comparison, the price ranges published on Good&Also's website are NT$100,000 to NT$300,000 for a basic identity, and NT$300,000 to NT$800,000 for strategy plus a complete identity. Once strategy research and video production are included, Hsinchu City's budget sitting above that range is not out of line with market rates. Good&Also publishes its ranges precisely so that the discussion starts from the items rather than the total, a point covered more fully in our guide to brand consulting fees.


Why Not Simply Replace the City Emblem with the City Brand Identity?


Because the two serve different functions. The Hsinchu City Government's position is that the city emblem represents the city's history and legal identity, while the city brand is the city's calling card for external communication; the two serve different functions and are used in parallel.

In concrete terms, the city emblem stays in formal use on official documents and certificates, while Carry on! is used for city marketing, tourism promotion, international exchange, and digital publicity. The controversy began when a netizen criticized the current city emblem as ugly on Facebook and questioned whether a second replacement by the city government would waste public money; the city government's response addressed exactly this point. It is worth being clear here: "second replacement" was the netizen's wording, not a fact the city government acknowledged.

Good&Also believes the city government made the right call. A statutory identity and a communication identity are two separate systems to begin with. Changing the former means going through legal procedures, not a design proposal; only the latter needs to adapt to the communication environment. Confusing the two is what creates the misunderstanding that introducing something new means rejecting the old, and almost every organization updating its identity runs into that misunderstanding at least once.

The identity itself draws on the texture of wind and the nurturing of water, taking the geometric curves of the Touqian River, the Keya River, and the Yangang River. Its colors run from a light, translucent blue gradient symbolizing the coastline to an energetic yellow representing technology and the light of dawn, and a twinkle symbol is embedded in the negative space of the letter O. This way of sourcing motifs is very common in city branding. Good&Also's view is that its success depends not on the graphics themselves, but on whether anyone actually follows the guidelines after the launch.


Running Two Identities in Parallel: What Does the City Give Up, and What Will It Cost?


What it gives up is the convenience of a single identity. Running two in parallel means the city government must maintain two sets of guidelines and two sets of usage occasions over the long term, along with a group of staff who know which one to use in which situation.

Good&Also's judgment is that the real cost of this arises after the launch, not within the tender. The tender buys a set of guideline documents, but getting dozens of bureaus and departments to choose correctly in daily official documents, event materials, and social media posts is ongoing governance work. It is usually not budgeted in the same line item, and few people factor it in when the contract is awarded.

Tainan City offers a useful comparison. On July 31, 2023, the city government tendered a NT$15,806,000 commission for Tainan brand and city image promotion, and on January 4, 2024, it separately tendered a NT$2.5 million city brand identity and signage demonstration planning project, for a combined total of more than NT$18.3 million. In August 2026 it was questioned over possible duplicate spending, and the Cultural Affairs Bureau responded that the two projects were entirely different in scope of work, purpose, and results.

The two cities actually faced the same kind of challenge: once a budget is split into several line items, it is hard for outsiders to piece them back together into one coherent undertaking. In public-sector identity projects, Good&Also maps fees directly to a list of deliverables, so that the commissioning agency has ready-made language for public explanations instead of scrambling to put it together only after being questioned. Where this habit comes from, along with several other checkpoints, is covered in 5 key visual decisions in the public-sector identity system design process.


How Should You Read a Brand Design Fee So It Isn't Misunderstood?


First look at how many things it buys, then look at the amount. If a fee cannot be broken down into items, it is hard to scrutinize whether it is high or low; only a quote that can be split into items gives you a basis for discussing whether it is expensive or cheap.

Good&Also's practice is to tie every fee item to a specific deliverable: which document the strategy research produces, how many applications the identity design covers, how many finished pieces the video production delivers. The benefit is not a better-looking quote; it is that cuts have a basis. When the budget falls short, what gets cut is an item and its corresponding deliverable, not a request to do the same thing for less.

Three principles to take away from the Hsinchu City case:

  • A quote must be breakable into items. A number that cannot be broken down cannot be defended, and when it is questioned there is nothing to respond with.

  • Handle the statutory identity and the communication identity separately; do not expect a single redesign to solve both needs at once.

  • Make the post-launch maintenance cost clear when drawing up the budget, because that is what determines whether an identity system survives.

If you are comparing quotes from different design companies, the criteria are the same as in this article: look at the itemized breakdown, not the total price. Good&Also has also put together evaluation criteria for choosing a brand design company, which deals with the question of selecting a vendor; to see which items actually make up the cost of identity design, read the complete guide to brand identity design costs. If the commissioning party is a public-sector agency, 4 key questions for evaluating design firms can be put to use directly.


Frequently Asked Questions


Is NT$1.2 Million Expensive for a City Brand Identity?

You can only judge that by looking at what it covers. Hsinchu City's budget included brand strategy research, logo design, a standard typeface, color guidelines and application design, and an image animation and marketing video production, six items in total, and video production and identity design have different cost structures. The total price alone cannot tell you whether it is expensive or cheap; you have to look at what each item actually bought.

How Are Brand Design Fees Usually Calculated?

The common approach is to price by deliverable item rather than by hours or by number of pieces. The ranges published on Good&Also's website are NT$100,000 to NT$300,000 for a basic identity and NT$300,000 to NT$800,000 for strategy plus a complete identity; the difference lies in whether upfront strategy research is included and how deep the application system goes.

Can a City Emblem and a City Brand Identity Coexist?

Yes, and that is exactly how Hsinchu City handled it. The city government explained that the city emblem represents the city's history and legal identity and remains in formal use on official documents and certificates, while the city brand is the city's calling card for external communication, used for city marketing, tourism promotion, international exchange, and digital publicity. The two serve different functions and are used in parallel.

Why Are Public-Sector Brand Design Projects Especially Prone to Budget Controversies?

Because procurement line items are divided by administrative category, not described the way ordinary people understand things. Tainan City split image promotion and identity design into two tenders, and was questioned over duplicate spending; the Cultural Affairs Bureau later explained that the two projects were entirely different in scope of work and results. Good&Also's recommendation is to publish a mapping of items to deliverables at the time of the launch, so the budget can explain itself.

How Can a Client Make Sure a Quote Isn't Padded?

Ask the vendor to break the quote into items, with each item clearly stating what is delivered, how many, and in what format. A quote that can be broken down can be compared item by item and cut item by item; with a quote that cannot be broken down, the two sides usually discover only halfway through the project that they had different understandings of the scope.


Brand Design Fee Controversies Are Mostly Not About Price


Hsinchu City's controversy went from launch to public questioning in six days. What was missing in between was not a budget explanation, but a list that matched the money to the deliverables. Brand design fees are often misunderstood because the public sees a single number, while the client has bought a set of things, and someone needs to be responsible for translating between the two. That job should be done by the design side at the proposal stage, not patched up after a controversy breaks out.

If you are not sure where your brand's problems currently lie, you can start with a Brand Checkup. Good&Also offers a 90-minute Brand Checkup service to help you clarify the core issues in your brand positioning, identity consistency, and market communication. Learn about the Brand Checkup service

 
 
 

Comments


​Let's Build Your Brand Together

​If you have any thoughts on brand strategy, brand naming, brand positioning, or brand design, please get in touch with us

我們會於工作日六個小時內與您聯繫

​

Phone
+886.2.2633.6189

​Subscribe to our latest brand insights

謝謝您的訂閱,請查閱您的信箱確認!

15F., No. 112, Sec. 1, Xinshi 3rd Rd., Tamsui Dist., New Taipei City 251, Taiwan

© 2026 Good&Also All Rights Reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page